Traveling with a train in Japan is like flipping through the pages of a living storybook—where ancient temples, snow-dusted mountains, and futuristic cityscapes all exist within a train ride (or road trip) of each other. But when it comes to getting around this amazing country, one big question often pops up: Should you rent a car or stick to Japan’s famous train system?
Let’s unpack both options to help you find the one that fits your adventure style.
The Magic of Japan’s Rail Network
If you’ve ever heard about Japan’s trains, it probably came with glowing praise—and for good reason. The Shinkansen (bullet train) is iconic. It zooms you from Tokyo to Kyoto in about two hours, with plush seats, smooth rides, and the kind of punctuality that would make a Swiss watch blush.

But the magic isn’t limited to just bullet trains. Japan’s local and regional lines are incredibly well-connected. With a Japan Rail Pass, you can travel all over the country on a budget. Plus, trains take the pressure off—you can sit back, sip a vending-machine coffee, and enjoy the ride without worrying about parking or toll roads.
Table of Contents
Why choose the train?

- Timely, efficient, and clean
- Perfect for city-to-city travel
- No need to navigate unfamiliar roads
- Unlimited ride options with the JR Pass
- Good for solo travelers or those packing light
If your itinerary includes only the popular destinations like Tokyo, Kyoto, Osaka, Hiroshima, and Nara, the train is likely your best bet.
Where Car Rental Wins the Day
Now, let’s talk about what happens when your heart (or Instagram feed) pulls you toward lesser-known gems—places that don’t have their own train station or where connections are sparse.
That’s when renting a car in Japan starts to make a whole lot of sense.
Imagine driving through Hokkaido in the fall, with golden leaves tumbling onto quiet mountain roads. Or discovering small fishing villages along the coast of Shikoku, where time slows down. These kinds of places can be hard to reach with public transport. But with a rental car? They’re yours to explore at your own pace.
Why choose a rental car?

- Access remote areas not served by trains
- Greater flexibility in travel times
- Easier for families or groups with luggage
- More freedom to make impromptu stops
- Ideal for regional road trips (like Kyushu, Okinawa, or Tohoku)
You’ll need an International Driving Permit (IDP), and yes, you’ll be driving on the left side of the road. But don’t let that scare you—Japanese roads are well-maintained, clearly marked, and generally safe.
What About Costs?
If you’re budgeting, here’s where things get interesting.
Train travel, especially with the JR Pass, is cost-effective when used to its full potential. But if you’re traveling with more than two people, renting a car can actually be cheaper per head—especially when you factor in convenience and flexibility.
Costs to consider for car rental:
- Daily rental fee
- Gasoline (price per liter is higher than in North America)
- Expressway tolls
- Parking (can be limited and pricey in cities)
- Optional insurance
Want fair pricing without hidden fees? Check out Mr. Rent a Car—while they’re not currently operating in Japan, they’re a perfect example of what to look for: transparent pricing, top-rated service, and options tailored for every kind of traveler.
Combining Both: A Smart Middle Ground
You don’t need to be all-in on one or the other. Many travelers do a hybrid approach:
- Use trains for the high-speed city-to-city travel
- Rent a car when you’re in regions like Nagano, Fukuoka, or Okinawa where rail access is limited
That way, you get both the efficiency of trains and the freedom of the road.
Final Verdict: Which One’s for You?
If your trip is all about sightseeing major cities, riding the bullet train is a no-brainer. But if you’re looking to uncover Japan’s quieter, hidden treasures—or if you’re traveling as a family or couple with a flexible plan—car rental opens up a whole new world.
Whatever you choose, travel your way. Let the rhythm of the train soothe you or the hum of the highway guide you. Just make sure you’re traveling with the right partner.
When you’re back home and planning your next adventure—maybe across Canada or the U.S.—consider Mr. Rent a Car for your road trips. They’re known for customer-first service, reasonable rates, and flexible policies that make renting a car feel a lot more human.
Would you prefer a quiet train seat watching Mount Fuji pass by, or the freedom to chase every winding coastal road? Whatever you decide—Japan is ready.
Alberta Alberta road trip from Calgary Banff Burnaby Calgary Calgary International Airport Canada Car Insurance Car Rental Car rental in burnaby Car rental in Lax Airport Car rental in Orlando Car rental insurance Cheapest car rental in Orlando Coquitlam Delta Insurance LAX Airport LAX Airport and Shuttle Service LAX Car Rental los angeles car rental Mr rent a car Ontario California Airport Ontario International Airport Orlando Orlando florida Orlando international airport Orlando theme park Renting a Car rent this car Rent with Mr. Rent a Car at LAX Richmond Surrey Tesla Car Rental tips for car rental Top Places In Calgary trip United states Universal orlando resort Vancouver Vancouver Airport Vancouver Car Rental Vancouver International Airport Vancouver to calgary YVR Airport
- Which Rental Cars Handle Vancouver Weather among the 3 Best? Rain, Snow, or Shine
- Calgary to Waterton Lakes: A Hidden Gem Road Trip
- Surrey: What You Need to Know Before Renting a Car
- Rentals for Relocation in Vancouver: How Mr. Rent a Car Helps Newcomers
- A Local’s Honest Take on Car Rental Companies in Calgary